Showing posts with label Seminary Work. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Seminary Work. Show all posts

Monday, April 23, 2012

Oh, Thesis

One of the biggest issues with theology is that at some point, somewhere along the road of life, the theologian is confronted with a situation that forces them to ask themselves, "Do I truly believe what I profess to believe?"

I spent a substantial portion of my time in graduate school declaring that I believe that reconciliation is at the heart of the Gospel, that reconciliation is God's primary intent for humankind, that reconciliation is of the utmost importance, that reconciliation ought to come before all else.

And then, I got the email.

First, some background.

On September 2, 2008, I received an email from a very old friend informing that this person wished to have zero contact with me.  Now.  In the future.  Ever again.

Okay.  Fine.  That, I can deal with.

And then, there was "The After."

"The After" was bad.

"The After" included lies and betrayal by a third party.  "The After" was all kinds of awful.  "The After" was stupendously horrid.  I mean, I am quite honestly at a loss for words as to just how terrible "The After" was.

It fundamentally changed and nearly destroyed my relationship with my best friend.

But, I made my expectations clear.  At some point this translated.  My best friend respected my boundaries.

But honestly, I never really got over "The After."

I still struggle with "The After" to this day.  Three years after "The After" ended.

But that is neither here nor there.  It's not really the point of this blog post.

This blog post is about the email.  And theology.  And being confronted with circumstances that test the strength of our convictions.

My method for dealing with difficult things in life is often to delve into scripture, find a way to deal with it theologically, and move on from there.

This is the method I chose to use when I received that email four years ago which ended a decade-long friendship.  And from that came my Master's thesis.  A thesis I dedicated to this person. 

The abridged version is below.  My introduction, interpretation, and concluding remarks.  I cut the 30+ pages of literature review for ease of reading, and because, honestly, does any blog post really need to be more than 15 pages long?

And so, without further ado, here is "the good parts version" of my thesis.  (More concerning how this thesis relates to this blog post to follow the thesis).

*****

I.  Introduction

It has been said that the church is a business.  If this is true, I am one very dissatisfied customer.  I have always wanted to know more.  The sermons I heard growing up left me feeling disconnected from the community of the faith I professed.  The sermons were cold, sterile, and frankly boring.  I felt that there must be more to the bible than what I was getting.  After all, it’s the best selling book of all time, and the single most frequently stolen book ever printed.  So it was that I began to study scripture for myself.  Once I was accepted to seminary, I began to take advantage of the opportunities and access to material this afforded me.

The idea for this thesis came to me in a seemingly roundabout fashion.  As a sometimes insomniac, I have come to discover that some of my best ideas come at 3:00 in the morning after a night of tossing and turning.  I was lying in bed one night and it suddenly hit me—there are so many parallels between the story of Noah’s Ark and Jesus’ baptism:  the forty days, the theme of the wilderness, the deluge, the wild animals, the intimate communication from and with God, the dove….  I started doing research and couldn’t find a single article that looks at these parallels.

Still fascinated, I began to research baptism in the first century and its ties to Jewish purity rituals.  I stumbled upon a journal article that changed my life.  It was an article concerning the Jewish miq’va and indicated one thing that stuck out clearly to me:  that all ritual cleansing must be done with water from a running (i.e. living) source.  This meant that water drawn from a well would have not efficacy if used in purity rites.  However, a single drop of water from a “living” source would make any amount of drawn water living water.[1]  I was suddenly struck by new meanings to be found in John 4 and the story of Jesus meeting the Samaritan woman at the well.

From this came a desire to look at other texts in which Jesus, water, and other people all come into contact.  So it is that I stumbled upon a new way of reading the story of Jesus washing the disciples’ feet.  I had heard several sermons preached on the foot-washing pericope in the course of my years attending church, and I was never particularly fond of the interpretation I heard.  Regardless of who preached the sermon, and when or where, all interpretations were the same—Jesus humiliated himself in performing an act reserved for slaves in order to demonstrate his love for his disciples; in applying scripture to our own lives, we, too, ought to serve others as a way to show people in our lives the love of God.

It isn’t that I do not, on some level, agree with most of this interpretation.  It is simply that I find it to be a very surface-level interpretation that fails to address more than a few verses of the pericope and which ignores the wider elements of the story itself, the Christological context of the entire book of John, and it fails to draw in other biblical texts dealing with cleansing and the Christological mission of Jesus which could, and I would argue, must be used to breathe new life into these texts as they are accessed in religious traditions in the twenty-first century.

In biblical interpretation, I believe it is necessary to look at a given text and learn as much as possible about the context in which it was written, the community for which it was written, and the ways in which the text was originally used.  However, there is a world of difference between first century Palestinian and twenty-first century American life.  As such, it is not enough to simply exegete a text.  One must go further, interpreting a text from the specific context of the interpreter, and finding ways to make a previously inaccessible text meaningful and significant for today’s readers and hearers of the good news.

I believe that the central message of the Christian New Testament is reconciliation: reconciliation of belief and practice, intention and action, of people to God, and of people to one another.  Jesus speaks explicitly of reconciliation in the gospels, and Paul makes liberal use of the notion throughout his epistles.  It is my belief that the foot-washing pericope can be read as a command to be reconciled to one another, and the action of the washing of the feet is itself as an outward, physical, manifestation of an inward decision to release another from their debt and restore right relationship.

This understanding of John 13 is significantly different from any I have encountered in either church settings or my research for this thesis.  Additionally, I believe that the whole of John 13 is geared toward this reading, and as such, must be taken as a whole.  One of the primary problems I encountered in doing my research was that the vast majority of the articles I was able to access looked at John 13:1-20.  A few articles included vv. 21-30.  Only two articles, however, dealt with John 13:1-38.  Additionally, I was hindered by the fact that I do not read Greek, and thus cannot access the text in the original language.  I am entirely dependent on the translations and mistranslations of others, and must accept on faith that their reading of the original Greek is accurate.  I find myself quite frustrated by this fact.

In this thesis, I will begin by reviewing the literature I have read, looking first at arguments for the unity of the whole of John 13.  I will then move onto foot-washing customs in the ancient world.  I will also explore how the foot-washing pericope is an ideal example of mentoring in the ancient world and a blueprint for those in ministry today.  Then, I will look at the seven most commonly held interpretations of the foot-washing itself, before turning to the characters in the story, looking specifically at how Jesus and his disciples interact in John 13—what Jesus knows, how he responds to Peter, what role Judas plays in the pericope, and where Satan enters the story, how Jesus addresses his disciples—and how the foot-washing has been instituted as a rite historically and in contemporary Christian communities.  Finally, I will give my own reading of the text and the conclusions I have drawn, interpreting the foot-washing as a model for reconciliation with the bounds of interpersonal relationship today.

Before I get to that, however, I want to say a word about the form of this thesis.  This is an interpretation of John 13.  It is not meant to be read as a factually accurate account concerning the historical Jesus.  Thus, when I indicate that Jesus has said or done something, that Peter or Judas has responded in a particular fashion, what I am presenting is what the characters of this particular text are saying and doing—not what the historical individuals themselves did.  As my intention is to make meaning from the text for myself and my own community today, I am engaging in what Sandra Schneiders calls “contemporary hermeneutics.  That is, my biblical interpretation is “concerned primarily with the meaning of the text itself, not with the author’s meaning.”[2]  As she says, “the meaning of the text is not in the past to be recovered, but in the present to be discovered.”[3]  I hope, in reading this thesis, you also discover something new.

 III.  Reading John 13 Today

The creation of the canon in the fifth century and the invention of the printing press in the fifteenth century have fundamentally changed biblical interpretation—and in a good way.  While the creation of the canon for some is quite problematic, one of the great things it did was bring multiple stories from multiple traditions and communities together in a somewhat unified whole.  As one interested in making meaning of the life of Jesus in present communities, having access to these collective stories is really handy.  It also frees me as an interpreter from having to hold to a single, and in antiquity possibly only available, text.  This allows for a richness in interpretation not previously allowed, even if it is not what the original authors intended.

The invention of the printing press made books so incredibly affordable that the possibility of biblical interpretation has now been opened beyond the tightly controlled strictures of the church.  While I believe there does need to be some measure of accountability in biblical interpretation—Does it make sense?  Does it fit with the wider context of the bible?  Is it responsible to the community in which it is expressed?  Does it maintain any connection to the history of interpretations?  Does it foster greater intimacy between the hearer and God?—I also believe that a multiplicity of voices, trained in a seminary classroom or in a bible study at the kitchen table, gives greater depth to our understanding of both the passage itself and ourselves as readers within our own communities.

This is my voice, how I read John 13.

What strikes me first about his passage are the things that Jesus knows: (1) that his hour had come to depart from this world, and go to the Father, (2) that the Father had given all things into his hands, (3) that he had come from God, (4) that he was going to God, (5) who was to betray him, (6) whom he had chosen, and (7) who would deny him.  Jesus, it seems, knows everything.

This knowledge of Jesus’ is sharply contrasted with the ignorance of the disciples.  They seem to not know much of anything  In particular, they are ignorant of (1) what Jesus is actually doing, (2) who among them will betray Jesus, (3) what Jesus is doing as he tells Judas to “Do quickly what you are going to do”, and (4) their, i.e. Peter’s, own ability to remain faithful to Jesus.

Jesus’ knowledge leads directly to his actions.  Knowing that all things are in his hands, that his origin and his destination are God, Jesus loved his disciples completely, to the end.  That love took the form of stooping before them and washing their feet.  While this may have been the job of a servant or slave in first century Palestine, it can not be read as act of humiliation.  What Jesus has chosen to do, he has chosen with full knowledge, from a place of genuine love and authenticity.  This is Jesus’ first action in what is to be the final act of his life—his glorification by God.  The very reality of this glorification denies any reading that indicates Jesus’ actions were about intentionally choosing humiliation, or even humility, i.e. choosing to make himself as lower than his disciples.  Rather, in washing their feet, Jesus makes the disciples clean.  In so doing, he raises them up to a position equal to his own.  Jesus isn’t lowering himself to another’s level; he’s elevating another to his own level.

In the process, Jesus gives Peter a lesson about the necessity of this washing—being clean is  a prerequisite to having a part with Jesus.  When he is done, Jesus returns to the table and teaches his disciples.  This teaching is striking in that it asserts four things: (1) though the disciples do not know what Jesus has done, they will in time, (2) that they must do for one another as Jesus has done for them, (3) that obedience to Jesus is a guarantee of blessing, and (4) that Jesus sends those whom he has chosen, and in receiving his sent, so is Jesus received, and in receiving Jesus God is received.

After this discourse, Jesus takes a piece of bread, dips it into the dish, and hands it to Judas.  It is this act which prompts Satan to enter Judas; only after this does Jesus tell Judas to “Do quickly what you are going to do,” sending Judas out to betray him.  Jesus sends Judas out.  Jesus is in full control of this situation; he chooses the time and the manner in which all things come together.  Indeed, all things are in his hands.

Finally, Jesus gives another teaching—that he is to be glorified, and in that glorification, will be leaving his disciples—and a new commandment.  This new commandment parallels his previous teaching—as he has done for them, so they must do for one another; as he has loved them, so they must love one another.  This is a love which is full, complete, genuine, and eternal—it is a transformative love until the end, which in terms of one who comes from God and is returning to God, is never ending.

IV.  Conclusions

So, what does it all mean?  How do we, who identify as Christ’s disciples today, love one another as Jesus has loved us?  What is the example he has set that we should follow?  I believe the answer to these questions is found in the mission of Jesus, in the relationship he had with God, and in the relationships he cultivated with his disciples.

From the beginning of the gospel of John, we see that the message of Jesus is one of reconciliation.  It is present from the very first verse: that in the beginning was the Word, which was with God, and was God; that through him all things were made; that coming to the world which he had created, he was unknown by that world, but to those who did receive him, he gave the right to become the children of God.  Jesus is the Word of God, and is God.  Though the many refuse to receive Jesus, for those who do accept him, he offers reconciliation for them to God their creator, by taking away the sin that separates us from God.[4]

In taking away the sin which separates humans from God and reconciling us to God, Jesus grants us eternal life—it is a relationship which endures forever.  God chose this as the method by which to reconcile the world to God’s self, because God loves the world created through Jesus.  The sole intention is to bring a world full of broken and messy people into the truth of who they are as ones created by God.  It is to bring people out of the darkness of their ignorance, and into the light of Jesus’ redemptive love.[5]

Because Jesus is the emissary of God, and because Jesus is himself God, those who welcome Jesus, welcome God.  Those who reject Jesus, reject God.  Choosing to honor Jesus is the only way to honor God.  Accepting and honoring Jesus then frees us from sin, and brings us into the family of God.  We are transformed from slaves to sin into sons and daughters in an eternal family, where we as God’s children, are accorded rich blessings and honor as well.[6]

Because Jesus is God, and is the son of God, no one can be reconciled to God, except through Jesus.  Knowing Jesus is knowing God.  Choosing to be in a love relationship with Jesus places us in a love relationship with God.  Loving Jesus means doing as he commands, and in loving Jesus, we are loved by God—and we are only able to love Jesus because he chose us, and loved us first.  Loving Jesus makes our lives the dwelling place of God.[7]

So, if we love Jesus, and in loving Jesus God dwells in us, then we are part of God’s family.  As such, we are automatically in fellowship with other children of God.  We are, therefore, commanded to love one another as Jesus has loved us—with the sameness of the love which God poured out upon him.  This is a love which goes to the cross, and willingly lays down one’s life for one’s friends.  We are given a promise in this; it is a conditional promise.  If.  If we love others with the same love shown to us, then we are called friends of God.  Then, we will bear the fruit of love—healthy, intimate, transformative relationships—as we remain in Jesus’ love, which keeps us in God’s love.[8]

Jesus completes his mission in showing the world God.  Jesus came that we might know him, and in that we might also know God.  Knowing someone means loving them.  To truly love another you must know them; and to know another, in all their messiness and glory, cannot lead to anything but love for them.  We see it time and again in the gospels—Jesus knows people, and he loves them.  Those who know Jesus love him.  Those who do not know Jesus hate him.  Even in their messy brokenness, knowing another moved Jesus to compassion; in the same way, it moves us to compassion, such that if we truly seek to know another as Christ knows them, and as Christ knows us, we cannot help but love them.

Using the story of the foot-washing as a model for loving others requires careful attention to the format of the text in our interpretation.  The foot-washing periscope itself is a chiasm.  Though Zorrilla sees a chiasm in this passage in which the main focus is the lasting relationship with Jesus, another chiasm is present in Jesus’ interactions with his disciples:

A.     Jesus engages Peter in the foot-washing (vv. 1-11)
   B.  Jesus charges his disciples to love one another (vv. 12-17)
      C.  Jesus engages Judas as his betrayer (vv. 18-30)
   B’.  Jesus charges his disciples to love one another (vv. 31-34)
A’.  Jesus engages Peter in his willingness/inability to follow (vv. 35-38)

In this breakdown of the passage, the central focus is Jesus’ interaction with Judas, who
betrays him.  For every action prior to Jesus’ engagement with Judas there is a corresponding action after.  Peter’s having his feet washed is resolved in his claiming willingness to use those feet to follow Jesus, and twice Jesus commands his disciples to love one another as he has loved them.

This chiasm must necessarily be contrasted with chiasm found in a larger section of John, chapters 13-21.  This breakdown would follow:

            A.  Jesus teaches and prays for his disciples (13:1-17:26)
   B.  Jesus is separated from his disciples physically by arrest and trial; and symbolically by Peter’s denial (18:1-18)
      C.  Jesus is questioned by Annas (18:19-24)
         D.  Peter betrays Jesus in his denial of relationship (18:25-27)
      C’.  Jesus is questioned by Pilate (18:28-19:22)
   B’.  Jesus is fully separated from his disciples by crucifixion and death (19:23-19:40)
A’.  Jesus is reunited with and teaches his disciples (19:41-21:25)

Again, the central element of this chiasm is betrayal—Peter’s betrayal of Jesus by his insistence that he does not know him.  Peter has chosen to walk away from Jesus, away from the relationship he promised never to abandon.  In doing so, he has chosen darkness over light, and failed in keeping the command of love.

What makes Judas any different from Peter?  The answer is found in Matthew 27:1-5 and John 21:15-19.   In Matthew 27:1-5, we get the rest of Judas’s story.  Let us remember that Judas left the table and went out to fulfill the act of betraying Jesus—and it was night.  Judas chose to leave the light of Jesus’ love and enter instead into ignorance and darkness.  The next morning, upon seeing that Jesus has been condemned, Judas repents.  He makes a genuine attempt to re-enter the light.  The darkness of shame is too heavy.  Judas goes before the chief priest and elders, proclaiming, “I have sinned, for I have betrayed innocent blood.”  In an act of remorse, Judas returns the sum he was paid for his betrayal, and he goes out and hangs himself.

At the end of the gospel of John, we see the resolution to the Peter’s betrayal.  Jesus and Peter are talking once more.  Jesus and Peter have come together again.  Peter, repenting from the sin of betrayal, insists that he loves Jesus.  Jesus accepts Peter’s assurance, and once again invites Peter to follow him.  Peter and Jesus are reconciled.  Judas never got that chance.

The gospel of John is clear:  It is sin which separates humanity from God.  It is Jesus who takes that sin away, and reconciles us once again to God.  Jesus remains in God, and God in Jesus.  Those who follow Jesus, remain in him.  We are charged, by Jesus, to remove sins from others, and in doing so, open the door to reconciliation between God and people.  If God is in Jesus, and Jesus is in us, in forgiving sins, and choosing to be reconciled to those who have betrayed us, we are ourselves reconciled to God, for God is found in all who are found in Jesus.  If we forgive another’s sins, they are forgiven.  If we do not forgive another’s sins, they are forgiven.[9]  In this, we fail to follow Jesus’ command to love, and deny others reconciliation to the Spirit of God within us.

I see in the command to wash one another’s feet a command to be reconciled to one another when betrayal has broken relationship.  When one party in a relationship betrays the other, they have walked away—out of the light of love, and into the darkness of ignorance.  They have chosen a road that gets their feet dirty.  Jesus commands us to wash their feet—to welcome them back into the light, with genuine love.  Betraying one who has shown you hospitality means leaving the relationship as that person’s enemy.  To be reconciled means to fully remove the stain of that betrayal from their feet, making the relationship right again, and creating peace between two people who have become enemies.

Those who would claim that the washing of feet is about the remission of post-baptismal sin miss the point of the cross.  The cross did it all.  Baptism is merely a sign of the work that Jesus did—an indication that we have moved from darkness to light.  Claims that foot-washing is about forgiveness undermines the power of the cross.  Foot-washing is about something more.  The forgiveness has taken place on the cross.  The reconciliation must follow in the washing of the feet of those we love—removing the last evidence that sin ever occurred, healing the brokenness, and permitting authentic, genuine love to be the mark of the relationship once more.  Judas wasn’t clean, not because he wasn’t forgiven, but because he never had the opportunity to be reconciled to Jesus.

What is the result of a refusal to be reconciled?  Those who do not accept the one whom Jesus sends, does not accept Jesus, and actively rejects God.  The command to the one returning, seeking reconciliation, is clear as well.  “If any place will not accept you or listen to you, shake the dust off your feet when you leave, as a testimony against them.”[10]  Refusing to be reconciled, so far as it is in our power to do so, is a risky maneuver, which places us in the judgment seat, as one who has failed to live up to the command to love—love others, love Jesus, and love God.  It leaves the dust of the feet of the other with us.  They have made the attempt, their feet are clean.  We now bear the sin.  Equally, walking away and not seeking reconciliation leaves us with dirty feet of our own.

What about when we are willing to be reconciled and the one who walked away does not want it?  Or when time and circumstances do not permit it?  Jesus gets it.  The reality of Jesus’ interaction with Judas leaves us with the knowledge that Jesus understands messy, broken people.  Jesus washed everyone’s feet—including the one who was to betray him!  Jesus declared all of them clean; except the one.  Why was Judas not clean?

If, as I have posited, washing another’s feet is about reconciling broken relationship, then something more must take place first.  Reconciliation cannot happen without forgiveness.  Forgiving, choosing to not hold another’s sins against them, opens the door for restoring relationship.  Jesus came to take away the sins of the world—the whole world.  This includes Judas.  Judas was forgiven.  He wasn’t clean because his relationship to Jesus was never reconciled.

How does any of this tie into the command to love others, to the point of laying down our lives for our friends?  When someone sins against us, and seeks reconciliation, we who forgive and are reconciled give up our right to hold a grudge.  We lay aside our pride and ego and we accept their will to restore the relationship.  In this one’s personal self is made subordinate to the creation and maintenance of the community and the communion we share with one another.  We do this, because as Jesus was an example of the love of God to his disciples, so we are examples of the love of Jesus to one another.  We cannot take part with Jesus if we walk around with dirty feet, whether by our own sins or our unwillingness to be reconciled to the repentant who have sinned against us.

Just as Jesus makes allowances for those relationships which cannot be reconciled, as was the case with Judas, we also see in Jesus’ final interaction with Peter a willingness to meet people where they are.  Peter has promised to follow Jesus where he goes.  Peter even promises to lay down his life for Jesus.  At the first moment of testing, Peter betrays him.

After the resurrection, as Peter and Jesus share an intimate moment, Jesus asks Peter, “Peter, do you agape me?”  Peter responds, “Lord, you know that I phileo you.”  Jesus asks again, “Peter, do you agape me?”  Peter responds, “Lord, you know that I phileo you.”  Finally, Jesus asks, “Peter, do you phileo me?”  And Peter, being sad that this third time Jesus has asked if Peter phileos him, responds, “Lord, you know all things.  You know that I phileo you.”

Peter has promised Jesus that his love is the genuine, self-giving, agape type of love; and he fails.  When Jesus questions Peter, Peter assures him that his love for Jesus is a brotherly love, the love of friendship, philia.  In many ways, this is as it should be.  They are both sons of God now.  Peter, having accepted Jesus, has been freed from sin and given the right to become a child of God.  Jesus, however, wants something more.  Jesus wants a genuine, authentic, transformative, agape love relationship with Peter.  Peter isn’t ready for that.  Not yet, at least.  Jesus says, “That’s okay, Peter.  I accept that you phileo me.”  We’re called to a standard that, at times, is impossible to reach.  Jesus gets it.  “It’s okay,” he says.  “Just do your best.”

The reality of life in this world is that we all walk around on dirty feet.  In the best of relationships, ones in which both parties truly share agape love for one another, life interrupts.  Things get messy.  Words are said or left unsaid.  Actions are taken or fail to be taken.  People walk away from relationships, sometimes by single steps, sometimes by what can feel like oceans of distance.  But if we are to remain in Jesus, we must obey his commands.  We must love another, laying down our pride, ego, and very lives for those we love.  When someone has walked away, upon their return, we must wash their feet and be reconciled.


[1] Stephen D. Ricks.  “Miqvaot: Ritual Immersion Baths in Second Temple (Intertestamental) Jewish History,” in Masada and the World of the New Testament, ed. John F. Hall and John W. Welch, (Provo, Utah: Brigham Young University Studies, 1997):  278.
[2] Sandra M. Schneiders, “The Foot Washing (John 13:1-20): An Experiment in Hermeneutics.” Ex Auditu 5 (2006): 136.
[3] Ibid., 146.
[4] John 1:1-29.
[5] John 3:16-21.
[6] John 8:34-36.
[7] John 14:6;20-23.
[8] John 15:9-17.
[9] John 20:23.
[10] Mark 6:11

*****
I wrote my thesis two years after the end of an incredibly significant relationship.

This was the thesis I wrote for my Master's degree.

I had hoped, in some way, that writing this thesis would bring me healing, some sense of closure.  To that end, it served it's purpose.  For the most part.  It allowed me to establish a boundary.  To tell myself, "I have done everything I can.  Now, I can let it go."

The day after I received my diploma, I sent a text message to this former friend of mine.  It was short.  Something to the effect of, "I just wanted to let you know that I received my Master's degree yesterday.  You were a significant part of the journey for a very long time, and I am taking this opportunity to say, 'Thank you,' for role you have played."

And then, I promised myself that if this person did not respond, I would not think of them.  I would consider the matter officially closed.  I would put it behind me, and think only of the future as I moved forward.

And that's exactly what I did.

Well, back in February, I got an email.  When I read the name of the sender, I thought, "Who is this and how did they get past my junk mail filter?"

When I read the subject line, "apology," I thought, "Surely not!"

When I opened the email, I realized, "Sure enough!"

It was brief.  Which is all the better.  Because it seemed more genuine, in my opinion.  It was pointed and specific.  In it's essence it read, "I fucked up.  I take full responsibility for the mistakes I made.  I acknowledge, point by point, that these are the ways I hurt you.  I acknowledge these are the choices I made to wrong you.  I am sorry.  Please forgive me."

Well, now, that's easy enough.  I was not at all affected by this email.

I was affected my lack of emotional response to this email.  I thought, "Four years ago, I would have given anything to read this.  Today, I read and think, 'Yep.  I know that.'"

So, I responded briefly, and I hope kindly, but clearly.  I wrote back, "You were forgiven years ago.  Be blessed."

And that was the end of it.

Or so I thought.

Eleven days ago, this individual wrote again, asking me to pray about the future regarding our friendship, and asking that I share my thoughts when I had come to a place of peace.

So, I did.

And the first thought I had was, "I wish I were 13 years old again, and had parents who loved me, and who would tell me, without my asking, with whom I can and cannot be friends."

My second thought was, "Well, suck.  I'm an adult.  I’m an autonomous human being. I have to make the decision independent of what others believe is right for me."

My third thought was, "Well, do I believe what I've claimed to believe?  Is reconciliation the prime objective of the Gospel?"

My fourth thought was, "Duh!  Of course it is.  Of course I believe what I've claimed."

My fifth thought was, "If reconciliation is defined as the restoration of right relationship, what the hell does right relationship even mean in these circumstances."

So, after a week long struggle and much prayer, I responded with a single word.

Fireweed.



In the subject line.

In the body of the email, I wrote about forest fires.

Specifically, I wrote:

"As I've been praying about the future of our friendship, if indeed there be any opportunity for a friendship, I keep coming back to the image of a forest fire and fireweed. Forest fires are actually quite necessary for the continued growth and health of a forest. Nature has, historically, taken care of this. The massive burn off eliminates weak or diseased plants and trees, allowing space for new, healthy growth.

"No one can predict with any certainty what shape the new forest will take as it grows in the coming years, decades, centuries.

"I've always been a very definite person. I do not like loose ends. I want things neat and tidy. And I have always wanted everything mapped out, in precise detail, with a clearly articulated and specific goal. As my relationship with God continues to grow, as I grow in faith and come to trust God more and more, I find myself more comfortable with the unknown, with uncertainty, with the holy openness that comes from the freedom found in the perfect love of our Creator.

"I do not want to put limitations on what God may or even can do. I know that any future friendship we may have will start slow. I also know that whatever shape it may take, it will look nothing like the relationship we had four years ago. I simply have no interest in any relationship that isn't healthy, vibrant, and marked by reciprocity and a respect that allows each individual to maintain their dignity.

"Much like the rebirth of a forest, however, any future friendship will, I believe, necessarily start small and grow and mature over the years. Rebuilding trust takes time. I am willing to give it a shot."

And then, I sent this person a bar of soap.

Saturday, January 28, 2012

Tyler Durden Meets Jesus



I think that watching the movie Fight Club may have helped me to reconnect with Gospel of Mark in a positive way. I’m not sure I don’t still hate the Gospel of Mark. I’m not sure I don’t still hate the Jesus portrayed in it. I think, though, that in some way I might be less angry with the poor provisional fixes offered by the Markan Jesus to those who have experienced loss or trauma.

In Fight Club, we see a man who has lost his sense of (masculine) identity. The loss of identity in a general sense is made clear in the fact that the narrator, played by Edward Norton, is never given a name and is listed in the credits as “The Narrator.” At several points, the narrator references himself in the third person, identifying himself as specific body parts, physical responses, and emotional experiences based on an article he read.

He says, “I am Jack’s (raging bile duct), (cold sweat), (complete lack of surprise), (smirking revenge), (wasted life), (inflamed sense of rejection), (broken heart),” and he does this both in voice-over and in speaking to other characters in the film. It is also made explicit in the narrator’s comments such as, “What kind of dining set defines me as a person?” It is further made clear in Tyler Durden’s comment, “We are consumers. We are byproducts of a lifestyle obsession.”

The fact that the loss of the narrator’s identity is specifically a masculine identity comes into focus in his attending a Testicular Cancer Survivor’s Group. This understanding is further made explicit with Tyler Durden commenting, “We are a generation of men raised by women, and I’m wondering if another woman is really the answer we need.”

In a community in which a large number of children are raised in single parent, female headed households, young men are not given any kind of indication of what it means to be men, of what masculinity looks like. Their only firsthand knowledge is an example of what is female and feminine.

In their striving to create a masculine identity, there is an almost total rejection of what is considered feminine and an embracing of what might be seen as opposite—made explicit in the refusal to discuss their fight club experiences outside of that setting and the use of violence as a means of creating community.

Additionally, there are comments in this film which are strongly religious, even Christian, tying it to the Gospel of Mark in ways that might not be seen unless viewed from the perspective of Mark as a paradigmatic overlay. In discussing his obsession with attending support groups, the narrator says, “Every night I died, and every night was I was born again; resurrected” and “Afterwards, we all felt saved,” in response to the weekly and then nightly fights taking place in the fight clubs.

Tyler Durden posits:

Our fathers were our models for God. If our fathers bailed, what does that tell you about God? You have to consider the possibility that God does not like you, never wanted you, in all probability, He hates you. This is not the worst thing that can happen. We don’t need Him. Fuck damnation. Fuck redemption. We are God’s unwanted children? So be it.

I wonder if this might be the sentiment of many in first century Palestine, having watched their cities burned, their families murdered, and the religious center of Israel razed to the ground. In their desolation and attempts to recreate a sense of community from the few scraps left, did they perhaps feel as though they were God’s unwanted children?

I was surprised and disturbed by the ways in which I saw the Gospel of Mark in the movie Fight Club. The loss of identity and the willingness of a group of individuals to follow a man who lived a schizophrenic life was so close to my understanding of the loss of community experienced by first century “readers” of the Gospel of Mark, and my own reading of the disciples following Jesus.

Furthermore, there is the creation of a new identity. Tyler Durden explains his purpose as follows: “All the ways you wish you could be, that's me. I look like you wanna look, I fuck like you wanna fuck, I am smart, capable, and most importantly, I am free in all the ways that you are not.” I think that this, in a lot of ways, is what Mark’s purpose was in writing this gospel—to create something, and someone in the person of Jesus, who is more, stronger, better, smarter, and fully liberated in ways in which the community was not, but wanted to be.

Ultimately, I think that Fight Club allows me access to the Gospel of Mark in ways that I did not previously have. Tyler Durden says to the narrator, “I will drag you kicking and screaming, and in the end you will thank me.” So too do I feel as though I am dragged through Mark, kicking and screaming; though with Mark, there is no end, for we are pointed, once again, to the beginning. We are told to go back to Galilee, to begin again, to be resurrected.

 “Only after disaster can we be resurrected,” Tyler says. In the aftermath of loss and trauma, we create new identities, identities that are no longer defined by, though not necessarily separate from, our former relationships (whether to people or things) which have been lost. In the face of loss and trauma our salvation is to be found in our ability to resurrect/recreate/reconstitute our own identities and understanding of ourselves.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

A Contemporization of Mark 5:21-43

When Jesus had again crossed over by boat to the other side of the lake, a large crowd gathered around him while he was by the lake. Then one of the synagogue rulers, named Jairus, came there. Seeing Jesus, he fell at his feet and pleaded earnestly with him, “My little daughter is dying. Please come and put your hands on her so that she will be healed and live.” So Jesus went with him.

*****

Thursday
08 November 2007
9:18am

I wake up this morning looking forward to checking my email. This is unusual for me. I am looking for an email. I know it will be there. It’s impossible that it won’t. I saw my mentor last night. I explained that I had sent him an email earlier yesterday and it was rather urgent. I was awaiting his reply. I understood when he explained how busy he was. I understood that nine children had died in the hospital that day and there had been no time to check his email.

He knew, now, however that I needed him. He knew that I had written him. I had stood in that classroom at Union Theological Seminary in the city of New York, room 303, and cried when he hugged me. He knew that I needed him. He had held me, breathed with me, and loved me. An email was waiting for me.

I scrounge around the floor, just trying to find something decent enough to wear as I make my way down the hall. I settle on the closest things, pulling on sweat pants and a sweat shirt and sliding my feet into loafers. I open my door and head out, turning down the hall. Michael Orzechowski and Kym Clemons-Jones are stepping off the elevator. “What are you doing here?” I ask, somewhat surprised to see them both in seminary housing.

“Actually, we’re here to see you,” Kym says. “We need to talk to you. Would you like to do it in your room or in the community room?”

I briefly consider the fact that I haven’t done laundry in about two weeks and my dog is not a fan of people coming in our room, and my desk is overflowing with papers and text books, untidy. “Let’s go to the community room,” I say.

Michael and Kym lead me down the hall and as we go I think to myself, What’s going on? What’s wrong? I haven’t done anything wrong. I begin to make a mental check-list of all the things I have done in the past three weeks. Nothing comes to mind that could possibly get me into trouble. Nothing illegal. Nothing unethical. Nothing against school rules or regulations. “As you can probably guess,” Kym says, “this is pretty serious.”

“Yeah,” I answer. “I kind of got that feeling.” My parents. My brothers. My sister. My nieces. Everyone sends bad news by email. Denis has already fallen off of two roofs—the first time breaking an ankle, the second time breaking an ankle, tibia, fibula, femur, and crushing his pelvis. If they can send this kind of news in an email, surely the only thing that would warrant a call would be death. But they would call me, wouldn’t they? Unless they’d lost my number. Unless they had to call the school administration because they couldn’t get a hold of me. When was the last time I had recharged my cell phone battery?

I take a deep breath and let it out. It does not matter what is going on. I am safe. I just have to keep breathing. Whatever this is, he can fix it. He can fix anything. If I can just keep breathing, make it through this meeting, I’ll call him as soon as Michael and Kym leave. I’ll call him, and I’ll tell him it’s an emergency. Whatever it is, he can fix it.

We’re in the community room, and Michael motions to me to take a seat. Kym closes the doors. Michael sits on the arm of the couch farthest from me. Kym stands in front of me. “He died last night,” Kym tells me.

I have one thought echoing so loudly in my head I cannot hear anything else: He cannot fix this.

Which is how I know it isn’t true. He can fix anything. If he can’t fix this, then it can’t possibly have happened. I shake my head. “No.” It’s the only thing I can say. “No, no, no, no, no, no, no.” I say it over and over and over again. It simply isn’t possible. I keep shaking my head, wanting to shake Kym’s words right out, make them go away, unsay them and burn away the memory of their sound. “How?” It comes out of my mouth, in my voice, but I know that I can’t have asked it. If I’m asking how then I must believe it to be true, and I know that simply isn’t possible.

“A heart attack.”

I sit there crying, Michael so far away he may as well not be there, and Kym standing in front of me like a nightmare come to terrorize my nights and rob me of sleep. “Do you need to go to the hospital?” she asks.

“No,” I tell her. “I’ll be okay.”

I do not know how long we sit there. I continue to shake my head and say, “No.” I look up at Kym on occasion and ask, “Really?” It doesn’t make sense. I cannot wrap my head around it. It’s too….to be real. It is the impossible. I can’t be near them. “I need some time,” I say. “I’m going to go to my room. Maybe take a shower.”

“The worship office is changing the plans for chapel today. They’re planning a memorial chapel. Maybe you want to join in the plans?” Kym suggests.

“Yes, I’d like that. I’ll head over now, shower later.” I get to the chapel and they are just finishing up. I go back to my room. I grab my towel.

I turn on the water, as hot as it will get. I sit on the cold marble stall of the shower, draw my knees up to my chest, wrap my arms around my legs, hang my head, and I cry. I sob. The water striking the back of my head hurts. Every drop is like a needle pricking my skin, stinging me where it lands. I cannot breathe. It hurts too much. I feel like I am drowning in sorrow. I may as well be surrounded by water. At some point, I get up. I turn off the water. I put clothes on. I go to chapel. I cry. I remember the way he said my name, “Mary Winkelpleck” in a tone that told me he was going to scold me in a really loving way. It always made me giggle. Remembering it makes me laugh. I do not sleep.

Saturday
10 November 2007
Morning

I have decided to create my own reality. I will continue to tell myself that this is a bad dream and that I will wake up. I will tell myself this until I believe it. I will tell myself this until I make it real—real for me and real for everyone else in this nightmare. This is just a bad dream and one morning I will wake up on Thursday, 08 November 2007 at 9:18am, and I will check my e-mail. There will be an e-mail from him in my inbox, an e-mail full of love and support and arrangements to meet at 1:45pm on Saturday on the park side of the street at 116 and Riverside Drive. Plans for me, Willy Wonka, him, and Casey. This is just a bad dream. This is just a bad dream.

Afternoon

I am in a women’s clothing store on 34th street. My phone rings. It is Anna. I answer. “I’m so sorry. I just heard. Are you okay?” she says to me without preamble.

“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I reply. I’m shopping.

“I just heard about him. Honey, are you okay?” Anna seems really worried.

“Oh, that! It was a mistake. They were wrong. It’s fine. I’m fine. Everything is fine!” I have started to shout into my phone.

“Mary, honey, where are you?”

“I’m buying panties!” I yell at Anna. “So, you see,” I tell her, my logic flawless, “he can’t be dead. Because if I can buy panties, the most normal, Mundane, BORING ACTIVITY IN THE WORLD, HE CAN’T POSSIBLY BE DEAD!” I’m practically screaming at her now. People are staring at me. “I’m buying panties,” I say, trying to rein it in. “Don’t you understand? People don’t just buy panties after the whole world ends. It’s not possible. And if I’m buying panties, if I’m capable of buying panties, then the world hasn’t ended. They were wrong. He isn’t dead. He’s just sleeping.”

“Mary, where are you? Where exactly are you? Tell me where you are,” Anna pleads.

“I’m buying panties. I’m in line now, I have to go. I need to pay for this. I’m heading home when I’m done. I’ll be in McGiffert for the rest of the day.”

“Promise me you won’t hurt yourself,” Anna pleads. “Promise me you’ll make it home safely.”

“Anna, why would I hurt myself? Everything is fine. I’ll call you later. I need to pay for this.”

I get home, put my new purchases away. I grab my bottle of vodka, a fifth of Smirnoff. It’s full. I grab a bottle of cranberry juice. I grab a movie. Miss Congeniality. A comedy. I’m going to drink and laugh until I can convince myself that this is not real. I sit in the common room. In less than 45 minutes the vodka is gone. The movie is playing, and I’m speaking along with the dialogue. I laugh at the funny parts. I cry.

I do not know why I’m crying. There are people around me. They are saying things. They are concerned. “I’m fine. He’s just sleeping. He’s going to wake up. Okay? He’s going to wake up.” Someone tells me that I have to face reality. That he isn’t going to wake up. I get angry. I cry. I yell at them.

Someone else sits next to me. It is Vanessa Cardinale. “It’s okay,” she says. “Guys, just leave her alone. Let her believe what she has to. It’s okay.”

Someone else keeps telling me I have to drink water.

“Water. H20. Did you know that water is made up of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom? Did you know that it has an atomic weight of ten? Two hydrogen atoms—each weighs one atomic unit, because they each have one neutron. One oxygen atom—it weighs eight atomic units, because it has eight neutrons. Eight and one and one make ten. That’s water’s weight. Ten.” These are the things I say to them.

Michael O. materializes in a corner. He says something to me. I can’t hear him. “Anna sent you, didn’t she?” I say. What a good friend, making sure that I’m okay.

Michael is still talking. I listen closely. “We need to go to the hospital,” he says.

“Oh, I’m sorry,” I tell him. “I’ll just go to my room. I’m sorry you had to come all the way out here. I’m sorry you had to waste the time. I didn’t mean to make a scene. I’ll get my stuff together and go back to my room.”

“You need to get your socks and shoes on. We need to go to the hospital,” Michael says again.

“I don’t want to go. I’m fine, really. I’ll just go to my room. I didn’t mean to scare anybody.”

“Marybeth, if you’re not willing to go to the hospital with me now, I’m going to have to call the police. They’ll make you go. I don’t want to call the police.”

“Oh. Okay.” I do not want to further inconvenience anyone. “I need some help. I can’t get my socks on. I wear toe socks,” I explain, beginning to cry. “I can’t get them on. Can someone please help me?” Vanessa begins to help me get my socks on. They are olive green, and sparkly dark purple, baby blue and lime. They are beautiful, fun, foolish socks, and they are designed like gloves for the feet, with a separate appendage for each toe. I point out the colors to Vanessa, just to make sure she knows what the colors are. We count my toes, “One. Two. Three. Four. Five.” Other foot! “Six. Seven. Eight. Nine. Ten.” Now my shoes. “Can you tie my shoes? I don’t think I can tie my shoes. Will you help me?” I ask Vanessa. Vanessa ties my shoes.
They want to take the elevator, which is ridiculous in my opinion. It’s a single flight of stairs. It’s lazy to take the elevator down a single flight of stairs. Don’t they understand this? I give in. We take the elevator. It’s probably a good thing. When we get to the four steps leading out of the building Michael O. is holding the door open for us. I have one person behind me, holding me up, one on my left, and one on my right. The people on either side of me lift my legs one at a time and place them on the steps. I cannot feel my legs. I cannot feel anything.

I am in Michael’s van, and he is driving me to the hospital. I am on a gurney. “We blew another vein,” a voice says. I can’t see anything. Just voices everywhere. I think, Another vein? I’m going to have two bruises tomorrow. “You have to use a butterfly. I have deep veins in my arms. You can’t get anything in my elbow. You have to use a butterfly in the back of my left hand.”
“We know, honey. You’ve told us. We’re trying,” a voice says. (I counted six bruises in my hand the next morning.)

I have to pee, and no one will let me leave the gurney. I ask to be escorted. They can even pick the person. I don’t care who goes with me. I do not want to experience the humiliation of a bed pan. They refuse. A bed pan it is. In the meantime, a friend who rode along to the hospital helps me undress and get into a gown.

I ask for an emesis basin. I fill it. My stomach rolls. I ask for another one. “I don’t think you’ll need another one,” a man tells me. “Judging by the amount, I’d say you got rid of everything in this one.

My stomach does not feel good. “Please,” I tell him, “I think I’m going to be sick again. I need another one.” He hands me another pink tub. He is right. I do not vomit again. Nor do I have the muscle control to hold onto the tub. I put it at the head of the bed, above me. I falls over, slips down. I end up wearing it like a hat.

I urinate in a bed pan. My worst fear. I urinate too much. It overflows. Why couldn’t they just have let me go to the bathroom? Someone takes the bed pan away to empty it. “Can I get a new sheet please,” I ask. “It spilled. This one is wet.”

A doctor comes. “Why did you drink a bottle of vodka this evening?”

She’s the emergency room psychiatrist. I do not trust her. “They lied about him. He’s just sleeping,” I tell her. I do not think she believes me.

“He is the man who died?” she asks, turning to Michael O. and Kym Clemons-Jones for confirmation.

“No!” I scream. Where did Kym come from? “He’s not dead. He’s just sleeping. Jesus woke up Jairus’s daughter in Mark 5 and he’s going to wake up him!” She turns to Michael and Kym to confirm that he is the man who died. Why don’t they understand? “Jesus woke up Jairus’s daughter and he’s going to wake up him!” I have to make them understand. I have to make them believe this. If I can convince just one other person, then maybe I can really believe it myself. I try to be gentler about it. “Jairus’s daughter wasn’t dead. She was sleeping. Jesus woke up Jairus’s daughter. They got it wrong, see? He isn’t dead. He’s just sleeping. Jesus woke up Jairus’s daughter, and he’s going to wake up him.”

I spend the night in the emergency room. Suicide watch. I do not sleep.

*****

A large crowd followed and pressed around him. And a woman was there who had been subject to bleeding for twelve years. She had suffered a great deal under the care of many doctors and had spent all she had, yet instead of getting better she grew worse. When she heard about Jesus, she came up behind him in the crowd and touched his cloak, because she thought, “If I just touch his clothes, I will be healed.” Immediately her bleeding stopped and she felt in her body that she was freed from her suffering.

At once Jesus realized that power had gone out of him. He turned around in the crowd and asked, “Who touched my clothes?”
“You see the people crowding against you,” his disciples answered, “and yet you ask, ‘Who touched me?’”

But Jesus kept looking around to see who had done it. Then the woman, knowing what had happened to her, came and fell at his feet, and trembling with fear, told him the whole truth. He said to her, “Daughter, your faith has healed you. Go in peace and be freed from your suffering.”

*****

I grew up in a really fucked up family. My father is an alcoholic and a drug addict. During my childhood, my father was emotionally and verbally abusive to everyone in the household. He was physically abusive to my brothers. I remember my younger brother’s pre-school picture. He has a fat lip. He’s three years old in the photograph, and he has a fat lip, split open and swollen because my father had backhanded him the day before the picture was taken. What does a three year old do to deserve being beaten up by a grown man whose upper body is corded with muscle from years of working construction, and whose blood runs with too much aggression from the amount of amphetamines, cocaine, and heroin he takes?

I remember this one time that my brothers and I had an epiphany. Dad always got more violent when he was drinking. He had come home with a new supply of beer that day and drank through half of it before passing out on the couch. If we could just interrupt the supply, he wouldn’t get so mean. We took the rest of the beer outside and began emptying the cans on the ground, watching the piss-colored liquid pool and foam before sinking into the gravel, turning the gray dust to mud.

One of my brothers wanted to know why Daddy drank it. He squatted down and dipped a finger in the beer, touching it to his tongue. “Don’t do that!” I said, filling with panic. “You don’t want to end up like him.” My younger brother takes a taste as well.

“It tastes disgusting. I don’t know why he drinks it.” But there was something in my brothers’ eyes that day that made me nervous. A fierce shining and a look of resignation on their faces. I wonder if at the ages of ten and seven they had a primal knowledge of the genetics of addiction, if they weren’t giving in, resigning themselves to what would become their lives at such a tender age. I was eight, and I knew I would never use drugs or drink alcohol. Those things just ruined your life and made you mean. They made you brutalize the people you were supposed to love.

Out of nowhere my brothers are both on the ground. A terrifying beast stands over them, five feet, nine inches of solid muscle. Long legs, long arms, and power. We had been paying such close attention to the beer we hadn’t heard our father approach. He began to kick my brothers viciously. Wearing his steel-toed, pointy, cowboy boots he kicks and kicks and kicks. I heard the blows landing as I watched my father’s boots connect with their backs, stomachs, legs, their arms as they covered their heads in self-defense. He yelled the whole time he was kicking them, telling them that they were sons-of-a-bitch, little bastards, where did they get off touching his things? When he grew tired, my father walked away. I stood helplessly by the entire time. I don’t think my father ever saw me.

“We have to tell mom,” I said, pleading with them. “She has to know what he’s like.” As though she didn’t already know. At least twice already my father’s had tried to kill her. Once he had pinned her to their bed, pounding on her with his fists. He broke her nose and gave her two black eyes. He told her he was going to beat her to death, and he meant it. She managed to grab the two-by-four he kept in their bedroom and he backed off.

The other time my father tried to kill my mother they had been out to a bar, and my father’s girlfriend had shown up. She began flirting with my father. When my mother confronted him, they came home. When they got to our house they sent the babysitter home. They argued, yelling at each other. It escalated. My father held my mother against the wall, his hands wrapped around her throat, her feet dangling several inches off the floor. My mother tried to plead with my older sister to call the police. But my sister was terrified. She couldn’t move. My mother started to black out, and stopped struggling, her body going limp. My father was still holding her against the wall, still squeezing. My older brother went to the kitchen, grabbed the telephone, and dialed the operator. Before he could even ask to be connected to the police my father had ripped the telephone from the wall and left.

On this occasion, having beaten my brothers for pouring out his beer, my brothers refused to tell our mother what our father had done. “We’re going to tell her we fell off our bikes when we were riding around town today.”

“You can’t do that. You have to tell her the truth,” I pleaded.

“What do you think he’ll do to us if we rat him out?” my older brother asked. “You have to promise you won’t tell mom what he did. He’ll kill us if you tell on him.”

“Maybe he won’t,” I argued. “Maybe she’ll finally leave him.”

“Promise!” he demanded. I told him I wouldn’t mention it to our mother. I lied.

When my mom got home from work that day and saw the scrapes and bruises on my brothers, they told her they had fallen off their bikes. She believed them. That night after everyone had gone to bed—my mother finishing up the dishes, my father out of the house, my brothers both sleeping—I snuck into the kitchen. “Daddy did it,” I whispered.

“What?” my mother asked, in a somewhat distant voice, as though I had interrupted a daydream, not having heard me as she carefully washed a plate, rinsed it, and placed in the dish strainer.

“Daddy did it. The boys didn’t fall off their bikes. We took Daddy’s beer up to the elevator and dumped it out. He found us and beat up the boys. He did it to them.”

My mother sighed. “Go back to bed. Everything will be alright in the morning.” I learned years later that my mother hadn’t believed me. She thought I wanted her to divorce my father. She believed that I was willing to say anything to make it happen. I love my father. I always have. When he passed out on the couch every night after too much beer or liquor, I would shake him awake before bed—every single night—for a hug and kiss goodnight. I do not think he remembers this.

When I was five, my older sister had a friend over to spend the night. My sister was nine, her friend was twelve. She did not spend the night. My sister’s friend forced my younger brother, who was three, to perform cunnilingus on her and to have sexual intercourse with her. She forced my older brother, who was six, and me to undress one article of clothing at a time and lie in bed together after taking off each article. When we were stripped down to our underwear, we refused to go any further. We knew that what she was trying to make us do wasn’t right. She refused to give us our pants back and made us watch while she raped our baby brother. My sister sat in the corner of the room just watching the whole thing unfold.

When we finally did get our pants back, my older brother and I went downstairs to watch television with our parents. When my younger brother came down and told my parents what had happened, they called the police. The girl’s parents came and took her home. The rest of us went to the police station. They would only take my younger brother’s statement because he was the only one who had been forced to “perform a sexual act.” What she did to my older brother and to me didn’t matter to them in light of this. We were not allowed to talk about what had happened. The police did not want to hear it. We weren’t allowed to talk about it at home. My parents didn’t want to hear it.

I began acting out in school. I would kick, yell at, and hit the other students. I threw my safety scissors, crayons, paste, shoes, books, and chair at the teacher. Strangely, the thing I feel most shame about is that one day, having been placed in the corner for a time-out, I dumped out all the puzzles, mixed the pieces together, and put them back into the boxes handful by handful. I am ashamed that this act created confusion when the boxes were opened next and no one could make any of the puzzle pieces fit together properly.

This incident with my sister’s friend was also the beginning of sexual abuse within the family. After my sister witness her friend sexual abusing my older brother and me, and raping my younger brother, my sister began sexually abusing me. I do not have many or particularly long memories of the abuse, but I do have specific snippets of memories of being forced to French kiss her, bathe with her and touch her genitals and one instance when she forced me to drink her urine.

Because of the problems at school, my parents took me to therapists—several. They would meet the therapist privately and then I would be sent in to meet the therapist. I knew that I was angry about the sexual abuse by my sister’s friend and the ongoing incest/molestation, but because I hadn’t been allowed to talk about it with the authorities, and because I wasn’t allowed to talk about it at home, I did not know that I could talk about it with my therapist. I also was under the impression that my parents were guiding the therapist in terms of what I was and was not allowed to discuss. I never broached the subject of the sexual abuse, and every therapist I saw wanted to talk about my father’s alcoholism. They all insisted that my father’s rage was a result of his drinking, his drinking a result of my failure to behave in school, and thus, if I wanted my family to happy, I had to learn to not get angry about my father’s drinking so he would stop. I never saw a single therapist for very long.
When I was ten, my father sexually abused me. It only happened once, but it was traumatic. Two months later, he came after me in a fit of rage and would have killed me if he could have gotten his hands on me. I believe these are the only two times in my entire childhood that my father saw me.

The night my father tried to kill me the police were called. I was suddenly invisible to him again, as he had beaten my brothers, and when the officer arrived, he threatened to strangle my sister in front the man. I was never looked at or referenced. My three siblings and I were taken into foster care that night. When my mother came home and found us gone, she kicked my father out and told him to never come back. Two months after this my younger brother and I were returned to my mother’s care. It would be another six months before my sister and older brother were returned as well.

My father entered rehab and got clean and sober. The physical and sexual abuse stopped. My father fought to win my mother back and four years later succeeded. I did not want to move to another new town and be under the same roof as my father. My mother put me in therapy again. With this therapist, being fourteen years old, I felt comfortable telling her what I needed. I explained the circumstances: the sexual abuse my father perpetrated against me, indicating that I was still very angry about this and insisting that I did not feel safe in my home, living under the same roof as this man. The therapist told me that my father’s sexual indiscretions (that is what she called his abuse) were the concern of my parents’ marriage and if I continued to insist on talking about it, she would not continue to offer me services. I attended another three sessions during which I said not a single word. Finally she told my mother that I was “uncooperative” and was wasting both the therapist’s time and my mother’s resources. I did not return to therapy.

Later that year, I was sexually assaulted while babysitting for a neighbor. I told no one. Two weeks later, I cut myself for the first time and knew I had found salvation. I continued to cut for seven years.

I did not want to cut. Having had my experiences denied the whole of my life, however, there was something soothing in seeing a physical manifestation of the internal pain no one was willing to witness, and about which I was not permitted speak. Cutting myself was an undeniable affirmation that I was human, and that my pain was real, and it mattered, even if only to me. When a razor blade slips through your skin like a sharp knife in a nectarine’s flesh it demands an acknowledgment of brokenness and pain. Even if you are the only person who ever knows, who ever sees, it cannot be run from or denied.

I fought with myself over the issue of self-mutilation for seven years. I desperately wanted to give it up, but I needed it to know that my pain was genuine. In those seven years, I never went more than three days without cutting, often cutting several times a day, every day, for weeks at a time. One time when no razor blades or knives were available, I gave myself a third-degree burn. It didn’t hurt. It didn’t bleed. It didn’t heal in the same way. I never burned myself again.

Seven years of this and it ended one night. In an instant I was healed. I was sitting in my car preparing to cut myself when I heard an audible voice speak into my right ear. “This is not who I created you to be. I want so much more for you. This stops now. Your identity is in me. This is not who I created you to be.” I never cut again. I began to get healthy. My relationships began to flourish. I hadn’t seen a therapist in seven years, and in one moment God healed me. Three years later I finished my undergraduate degree, was accepted to Union Theological Seminary, moved to New York City, and did not look back.

*****

While Jesus was still speaking, some men came from the house of Jairus, the synagogue ruler. “Your daughter is dead,” they said. “Why bother the teacher any more?”

Ignoring what they said, Jesus told the synagogue ruler, “Do not be afraid; just believe.” He did not let anyone follow him except Peter, James and John the brother of James.

When they came to the home of the synagogue ruler, Jesus saw a commotion, with people crying and wailing loudly. He went in and said to them, “Why all this commotion and wailing? The child is not dead but asleep.” But they laughed at him.
After he put them all out, he took the child’s father and mother and the disciples who were with him, and went in where the child was. He took her by the hand and said to her, “Talitha koum!” (which mean, “Little girl, I say to you, get up!”). Immediately the girl stood up and walked around (she was twelve years old). At this they were completely astonished. He gave them strict orders not to let anyone know about him, and told them to give her something to eat.

*****

I was living in New York City, attending Union Theological Seminary. More importantly, I was living. This is where I met him, my mentor. He loved me. He loved me so well. He was the incarnate Christ in my life. According to Ron Belsterling, the term mentor may come from the root “meno (enduring relationship).” This is “an abiding relationship, the type of relationship [Jesus] desires with His twelve disciples.” There are not words for what I lost when he died.

Tuesday
13 November 2007
Morning

My mentor died six days ago. I am going to his funeral. I carefully choose my attire. I have a black, pin-striped suit. He loved how it looks on me. I am wearing black, strappy, open-toed, high heels. Carefully, I make my way from my room to Riverside Church. I sign the guestbook. I enter the sanctuary. I am flanked by friends. There is reserved seating for a group of us. Half-way down the aisle I stop, striving to move forward, trying to exert my will upon my body, which has decided at this moment to move backward. I am pulled along by my friends. I feel as though I am walking headlong into gale-force winds.

People talk. People sing. Some man plays a trumpet. A pastor says, “Into your hands, we now commend his spirit,” and it hits me. This is the moment that he is truly gone. This is the moment that his spirit truly leaves us. Until this moment, it was possible that he might come back. Now, this man, the pastor, has ripped his spirit from our hearts and placed it in God’s hands. I begin to shake my head no. This is not possible. He cannot be gone.

Wednesday
14 November 2007
8:00am

I am on a plane. I am leaving New York City and returning to Iowa. My best friend has agreed to let me live with her for the next year, until I return to Union to finish my degree. When the plane lands, I collect my luggage, climb into the truck she and her husband have left for me in the parking lot. I drive to their house, carry my things inside, and collapse into bed. I cry until my eyes run dry.

November

I stare at a wall. Matte rose. Dull fuchsia. I cannot tell. I barely sleep, though I spend eighteen hours a day in bed. When my body aches (from being in one position for so long) so severely that I can no longer stand it, I make my way downstairs and lie on the couch. Sometimes I stare at the wall. Sometimes I stare at the moving pictures on the television screen. Are those people? Are they saying something? I think I take a shower once.

December

I stare at a wall. Matte Rose. Dull fuchsia. I cannot tell. I barely sleep, though I spend eighteen hours a day in bed. When my body aches (from being in one position for so long) so severely that I can no longer stand it, I make my way downstairs and lie on the couch. I eat sugar. I wash dishes. Sometimes with the water running, I think I remember him. I leave. The water is still running. It overflows into the next sink and goes down the drain. A few hours later I come back and turn the water off. I lie on the couch and stare at the wall. I try to go back upstairs to bed. I am so tired I curl up on the stairs half-way up and take a nap. When I awaken, I crawl on my hands and knees to the top and into my room. I sleep on the floor, too tired to lift myself into the bed. I take a shower one day.

January

I stare at a wall. Matte Rose. Dull fuchsia. I cannot tell. I barely sleep, though I spend eighteen hours a day in bed. When my body aches (from being in one position for so long) so severely that I can no longer stand it, I make my way downstairs and lie on the couch. I eat sugar. I wash dishes. I stare at the wall. I stare at the wall. I think I take a shower twice.

February

I stare at a wall. Matte Rose. Dull fuchsia. I cannot tell. I barely sleep, though I spend eighteen hours a day in bed. When my body aches (from being in one position for so long) so severely that I can no longer stand it, I make my way downstairs and lie on the couch. I eat sugar. I wash dishes. I stare at the wall. I stare at the wall. I think I take a shower twice.

March

I get a job. There is no way my friend can make ends meet with her husband at boot camp, not being paid. She needs me to help. I go to work at 6:00am. I get home at 9:00am. I lie on the couch. I stare at the wall. I go to work at 2:00pm. I get home at 4:30pm. I lie on the couch. I stare at the wall. At night, I climb the stares, crawl into bed, and stare at the wall until I sleep. I shower once a week.

April

I go to work everyday. I go to church every weekend. In the in-between times, I sit on the couch. I stare at the wall. My mom comes over after she gets off work. She spends time with me. Once, she gives me a ride to the chiropractor. We stop by her house for lunch. We pull into the driveway. She leans across the van, gives me a hug and says, “I’m sorry you’re so sad.” I start to cry. My mother immediately releases me and gets out of the van. It is the only time anyone in my family mentions what I’m going through.

I begin working with a therapist. We meet every other week. Mostly, I cry. I miss him. There are so many things I did not get a chance to say. There are so many things I never got ask. There is one thing I did not take the time to say. I write a letter to him, saying the one thing. It took me two weeks to write it. I did not finish it. I just ran out of time. I shower twice a week.

May 2007-August 2009

I work. I go to church. I spend time with my mother. I go to therapy. I make new friends. I get healthier.

August 2009

I return to New York City. I return to Union Theological Seminary. I shower nearly every day. Jesus has not awoken me. Jesus has not resurrected me. I woke me up. I rebuilt my life. But, I have a different life now. It is not the life I wanted. It is not the life I planned. It is, however, the only life I have. I am finally living again.

Yet, I find myself living without the simple, easy relationship I’ve had with Jesus my whole life, a Jesus who never let me down, a Jesus who protected me in the midst of my traumatic upbringing; a Jesus who was with me as I got healthy; a Jesus who healed me of self-mutilation in an instant; a Jesus who was God incarnate, imbued with all of God’s substantial power and gifts—omniscience, omnipotence, omni-benevolence; a Jesus who is perfect; a Jesus who could and would love me to the ends of the earth, for all eternity.

Now, I have a life with a Jesus who is human. It’s a life with the Jesus of the Gospel of Mark; a Jesus who doesn’t heal anybody, because it is their faith that makes them well; a Jesus who doesn’t resurrect people, because “The child is not dead but asleep”; a Jesus who fails; a Jesus who failed me the moment I needed him most. It’s a life that returned to trauma after being delivered from so much trauma—the new trauma so much worse for the fact that it had been interrupted, finally, by an understanding of how God intended for us to love and be loved by one another. A life in which this trauma utterly broke me, and I had to pick up the pieces, patch them back together, and try to create something that resembles a whole. It’s a life that hurts more for the love I found in the in-between time, in the interruption, the time with him, my mentor. In losing him, I lost everything because it fundamentally changed the entire landscape of my life.

In the Gospel of Mark Jesus is always being interrupted. Or doing the interrupting. He interrupts illness with health; possession with freedom; death with life. And he still dies in the end. His death is more traumatic for those who knew him because he had delivered them from their trauma and shown them the love of God in real, tangible, manifest ways. In the end trauma, loss, and death have the final word. We are left to figure out how to pick up the pieces and create a life without him, because the Jesus I needed wasn’t there, and the Jesus I have, isn’t the one I want. He is, however, the only Jesus I have. Perhaps one day, together, we’ll find wholeness and create something new.